[collage by Andrew Sunfrog]
(part one of me riffing on the new U2 record)
We were hungry for this new album, I will admit it. The surprise EPs were in themselves satisfying, but they only sparked another appetite that I hoped the full-length album & subsequent tour might sate.
But even though I knew how deep the ache, I was not anticipating the purple, gold, & green sprinkles of this glorious King Cake. Not like we really asked for something simultaneously this weird & wondrous, this sublime & sanctified, but they showed up & showed us.
Not to put too fine a point on it, but U2 have invigorated ordinary time & reimagined the entire liturgical year. With Carnaval de Luz, they leaned into the liminal gap between Epiphany & Ash Wednesday & imbued it with a longer lens, as we linger in the light of new theological meanings.
Over the last few days, I have enjoyed watching some rock critics try to make sense of the brand-new liturgical prequel to Days of Ash & Easter Lily. Some of these writers dabble in religion, but most are riding the buzz of how this latest installment from the Dublin quartet surprises & rewrites their own legacy & canon.
But I am, & will be, completely obsessed with the spiritual & religious significance of Carnaval de Luz.
Not to hide the thesis, I think U2 has asked Christians to reconsider Carnival & incorporate its “defiant joy” into the arc of their devotional year. Even further, rather than categorize this celebration as some kind of wink-wink secret slippage into the hedonistic profane (which some of us saw in their entire 90s catalog), this is the holistic inclusion of humans finally including what God always included.
Some iterations of Carnival are simply upside down insurrections to undermine ecclesial authority. That’s not really what’s going on here. Some might say that this gap in time lets the devil sneak in & run roughshod over dignity & decency. But sometimes even the pious don’t need more piety.
Some chaos is beauty on a bad hair day. But U2 are a band that have never ever lost sight of how cruciform beauty is its own precise & profound chaos, a human divinity that disrupts the world more than any party-for-partying’s-sake ever did.
That is to say, on this album as when they took on the MacPhisto makeup, U2 defy the devil with a grit & grace I find rare in the mirrored hallway of late empire. Even more, this album reveals some of U2’s most effusive eschatological glimpses of heaven & glory. There are some spicy Pentecost vibes in this Carnival. The spirit showed up!
Radical equality, radical unity, & an upside down where the last are first, these are all Christian & Carnival themes. Critics (& myself occasionally if I am honest) have cynically misinterpreted U2’s aspiration for a radical center as mealy-mouthed hypocritical & cowardly both-sides-ism. If I listen with an open heart & mind to the new Torn duet with Dolly Parton or the fierce eulogy for Renee Good on Days of Ash, I cannot maintain such eye-rolls.
Years ago in recovery, I learned that God doesn’t have grandkids. We are all God’s kids, full stop. I learned from Dorothy Day that “I really only love God as much as I love the person I love the least.”
Unconditional universal love is what U2 are about, for better & for worse, on new albums & on all the old ones. It may be a foolish form of idealistic courage, but it’s not the empty-chested accommodationism that its accusers are so quick to point out.
After the Songs Of Innocence iPhone debacle, the saying “nobody is asking for a new U2 album” took on a new intensity in the cultural waters. I think U2 take all their critics way too far to heart. I didn’t hate Rattle & Hum like some, & I love the Songs Of cycle.
But U2’s own demands on themselves to defy every expectation gave us Achtung Baby & Zooropa, to answer the backlash to their sepia-soaked blues rock. So keep challenging your bad selves, boys!
Today, any perceived “meh whatever” about the Songs Of period could be reconsidered, it was actually a productive & prolific time, where the excellent memoir & the anniversary tour for Joshua Tree & Sphere residency for Achtung Baby, where all these may have overshadowed the two albums of new material from that period.
Thanks to this back & forth within themselves, though, & within the critical industrial complex, Carnaval de Luz is a crisp & prophetic reply. Well, if all of this work & waiting & critical debate are the pretext for this gloriously goofy & generous Carnaval ride, then so be it. I am getting on the ride. As soon as I get off, I buy another ticket & ride again. It’s that good.
A little more religion: How to put it nicely? I live in a part of the world where some of the Protestants just don’t know how to party. They don’t know how to party, & they don’t like to repent anymore either, as is with the heretical theology of MAGA. They don’t get Carnival & don’t need Lent.
(Although on another day, we could explain how J6 was the crudest carnivalesque & how 45/47 is an ultimate unholy fool king who would make even MacPhisto blush. But save that for another day.)
The same Protestants that don’t party don’t seem to really need the wilderness walk of a Lent or even a Holy Week, as much as they recreate Jesus Christ as an AI-generated-muscle-man kicking ass as he kicks open the tomb as though Easter Sunday was a Reality Show stunt.
Sure, some millennial exvangelicals & deconstructing progressives who grew up in non-denominational megachurches have discovered things like liturgy & the revised common lectionary & contemplative practices that swing back to the ancient church. Sure, some of them skipped the detour in the mainline & went straight to the whiskey bar with the other Nones.
But all of this is to say, I think U2 have brought very much into the mainstream conversation the devotional importance of following the liturgical year & its many smaller moments, its colors & its rituals. I think we all crave this level of meaning & connection.
This new U2 album releases at the exact time when all of America is revisiting the importance of its mainline Christian denominations that are very much liturgical, its Presbyterians & its Methodists & the Black Church that Bono is always talking about, & so on, at the time when so many preachers from those traditions have sought & been elected to political office, all to the end, as James Talarico puts it, of implementing a politics of love.
We have walked into this new album during another liturgical gap. It’s almost Advent, always a restless time. On the cloudy cusp between All Saints Day & Advent, on a cloudy November morning, release day is the dawn when the world has awoken to the “reenchantment of the world.”
“Reenchantment of the world” is an apt cultural studies phrase that has been swimming around for awhile, & Bono invokes it in the lyrics of this album (on Rosalia). That is what this record is about: reenchantment. I argue that they invited us into a deepening resonance for the entire liturgical year, & yes, some of the sympathetic critics are correct, this is also a welcome reinvention of their entire project, as they have done repeatedly through their career.
Or maybe we could say it this way, it’s time to just let U2 be U2 again—& for always.
-Andrew Sunfrog, on 11/13/2026, the feast day of Saint Frances Xavier Cabrini (Mother Cabrini)

No comments:
Post a Comment